Brooklyn 4U
  • Home
  • Agents
  • Sales
  • Rentals
  • Open Houses
  • About
  • Contact
  1. Home
  2. 5419 4th Avenue
  • 5419 4th Avenue
  • $ 2,800,000
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220

5419 4th Avenue

Sunset Park   |   54th Street & 55th Street

Building For Sale
$ 2,800,000
Ownership Mixed Use
Lot Size 25'x80'
Status Active
Real Estate Taxes [Per Annum] $ 15,415
Building Size 25'x65'
Year Built 1931
ASF/ASM 4,551/423
 

Photos

5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220

Maria Castellano

License Licensed As: Maria Castellano

Licensed Real Estate Broker/Owner


W: 718-236-1800
M: 917-318-1775
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220

Property Description

Prime Sunset Park mixed-use investment opportunity! Solid brick 3-story building + cellar featuring one commercial storefront and four residential units above, totaling approx. 4,551 SF on a 25×80 lot (R7A zoning). The property is fully occupied with reliable tenants, offering stable cash flow and strong upside potential. Each unit is separately metered for gas & electric and features gas-powered heat and hot water systems. Recent tax approx. $15,400 (2024) — keeping expenses low. Additional highlights include a flat roof, poured-concrete foundation, and a private rear yard. Conveniently located along 4th Ave between 54th & 55th St, just minutes to subway, shops, and restaurants — one of Brooklyn’s most desirable high-traffic corridors. Perfect for 1031 exchange, long-term investors, or owner-users looking for commercial + residential income under one roof. Don’t miss this rare chance to own a true Sunset Park income-producing gem.
Prime Sunset Park mixed-use investment opportunity! Solid brick 3-story building + cellar featuring one commercial storefront and four residential units above, totaling approx. 4,551 SF on a 25×80 lot (R7A zoning). The property is fully occupied with reliable tenants, offering stable cash flow and strong upside potential. Each unit is separately metered for gas & electric and features gas-powered heat and hot water systems. Recent tax approx. $15,400 (2024) — keeping expenses low. Additional highlights include a flat roof, poured-concrete foundation, and a private rear yard. Conveniently located along 4th Ave between 54th & 55th St, just minutes to subway, shops, and restaurants — one of Brooklyn’s most desirable high-traffic corridors. Perfect for 1031 exchange, long-term investors, or owner-users looking for commercial + residential income under one roof. Don’t miss this rare chance to own a true Sunset Park income-producing gem.

Listing Courtesy of Exit Realty Professionals

Maria Castellano

License Licensed As: Maria Castellano

Licensed Real Estate Broker/Owner


W: 718-236-1800
M: 917-318-1775

Care to take a look at this property?

Apartment Features

Exposed Bricks
Hardwood Floors
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220
5419 4th Avenue Sunset Park Brooklyn NY 11220

Building Details [5419 4th Avenue]

Ownership Mixed Use
Block/Lot 823/2
Building Size 25'x65'
Zoning R7A
Year Built 1931
Floors 3
Lot Size 25'x80'

Mortgage Calculator in [US Dollars]

$
%
$
%

Loan Amount

Maria Castellano

License Licensed As: Maria Castellano

Licensed Real Estate Broker/Owner


W: 718-236-1800
M: 917-318-1775
BNYMLS All information furnished regarding this or any property listed for sale or rent is gathered from sources deemed reliable. Though we have no reason to doubt the accuracy or validity of this information, we make no warranty or representation as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or withdrawal without notice. It is strongly recommended that the prospective purchaser or tenant shall carefully review each item of size, dimensions, real estate taxes, expenses, legal use and any other information presented herein.
All information furnished regarding property for sale, rental or financing is from sources deemed reliable, but no warranty or representation is made as to the accuracy thereof and same is submitted subject to errors, omissions, change of price, rental or other conditions, prior sale, lease or financing or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions are approximate. For exact dimensions, you must hire your own architect or engineer.
MLSID: 497166